Skip to content
New soup recipes, straight to your inbox every Friday. Sign up free

Editorial Guidelines

This page is the standard SimmerStead holds itself to. I am Elsie Bendrow, and SimmerStead is a soup kitchen before it is a website. The line on the masthead, real stock, slow simmer, no shortcuts, is not a slogan. It is the rule a recipe has to pass before it earns a page here.

Who writes here

One person. Me. Every recipe, every test pot, every photograph. If a soup comes from a region, a family, or a cook I learned it from, that is named at the top of the post. I do not republish someone else’s recipe text. I cook it, taste it against what I know, rebuild it in my own words, and credit where it came from.

How a recipe earns a page

Nothing publishes on a single pot. The minimum is three real cooks:

  • Cook one is the draft. I make it as written, time every stage, and write down what went wrong. Stock that tasted of nothing, a stew gone stringy, a chowder that broke.
  • Cook two is the fix. I change what cook one exposed, usually the simmer time, the salt, or the order things go in the pot, and cook it again with a record of what moved.
  • Cook three is the lock. I make the fixed version with nothing special on the counter, the way a reader would on a weeknight. If the bowl lands, it is locked. If it does not, I go back to cook two.

Simmer times, salt levels, and pot sizes in a recipe are the numbers from the cook that worked, not numbers copied off another site.

Stock, and the no-shortcuts rule

A soup is mostly its liquid, so the liquid gets treated seriously. Recipes here are built and tested on real stock, and where a stock is the point of the dish I give you the method for it. I am not precious about it, though. If you are reaching for a good store-bought broth on a Tuesday, the recipe tells you how to adjust the salt for it and what you trade away. Honest guidance beats a rule nobody follows.

Where the facts come from

Cooking is mostly experience, but anything stated as fact carries a source. Claims about food safety, such as how long a soup keeps or how to cool a big pot down before it goes in the fridge, follow established food-safety guidance rather than kitchen folklore. Where something is my own preference, I say so plainly instead of dressing an opinion up as a rule.

Images

The images on this site are produced in house to show what a dish looks like. They are not pulled from a stock library, and they are digitally created and edited rather than a single studio photograph of one hand-plated bowl. Read them as a guide to the result you are aiming for, not as a literal photo of the exact pot that produced the recipe.

Where AI fits, and where it does not

Every recipe site gets asked this, so here is the plain answer. AI helps me with spell-check, with checking I have not repeated myself across posts, and sometimes with rearranging an outline I then rewrite. It does not decide what to cook, invent a simmer time, or write the part where I tell you what went wrong on cook two. The voice on this site is one cook’s voice.

Corrections

If a recipe did not behave the way I said it would, tell me through the contact page. Results shift with stove, pot, and stock, and I would rather fix the note than leave you guessing. Corrections are made in the post itself with a short line saying what changed and when.


Last updated: 22 May 2026.